In South Africa, the town of Queenstown scores 85/100 for safety while Johannesburg scores 41 — a 44-point gap inside one country. These are the nations where "is it safe?" has no single answer, because one city is calm and another quite unsafe, often a domestic flight apart.
Ask "is South Africa safe?" and there is no honest single answer: the seaside town of Queenstown scores 85/100 while Johannesburg scores just 41 — a 44-point gulf inside one set of borders, the widest city-to-city safety spread of any country we track.
Travel advice is written at the level of the country — a single colour on a government map, a single line in a guidebook. But safety isn't distributed evenly inside a border. Kakapo scores individual cities, so we can measure something no country-level index can: the internal spread, the distance between a nation's safest major city and its least-safe one. When that gap is large, the country's reputation tells you almost nothing about the trip you'll actually have.
| Country | Safest city (score) | Least-safe city (score) | Spread |
|---|---|---|---|
| South Africa | Queenstown 85 | Johannesburg 41 | 44 |
| Venezuela | Valencia 82 | Caracas 42 | 40 |
| United States | Maui 92 | Baltimore 57 | 35 |
| Brazil | Florianópolis 82 | Rio de Janeiro 52 | 30 |
| Ecuador | Cuenca 87 | Guayaquil 57 | 30 |
| Mexico | Puebla 86 | Tijuana 57 | 29 |
| Philippines | Palawan 83 | Manila 58 | 25 |
| India | Shimla 82 | Delhi 58 | 24 |
| Peru | Puno 73 | Lima 53 | 20 |
| Italy | Bergamo 88 | Naples 69 | 19 |
| Spain | Salamanca 88 | Cartagena 69 | 19 |
| Dominican Republic | Santiago de los Caballeros 80 | Santo Domingo 61 | 19 |
| Canada | Hamilton 92 | Winnipeg 74 | 18 |
| Australia | Newcastle 91 | Darwin 74 | 17 |
The pattern isn't random. The most divided countries tend to pair a large, economically strained metropolis — where crime, traffic and inequality concentrate — with a smaller regional city, a coastal town or a wealthier provincial capital that stays calm. Johannesburg against Queenstown, Caracas against Valencia, Rio against Florianópolis, Tijuana against Puebla: in each case the famous name at the bottom drags the country's reputation down, while the quieter city at the top is invisible to most travellers. The spread is really a story about how uneven a single country can be.
Treat the country name as a starting point, not a verdict. Before you book, look up the specific city's score — in the divided countries a single domestic flight can move you 30 or 40 points up or down the scale. It cuts both ways: a country with a fearsome reputation may hold a city that's calmer than where you live, and a country that feels "safe" on paper may hold a city that deserves real caution. The unit that matters is the city, and often the neighbourhood inside it.
We took every country in Kakapo's database with at least three scored major cities (population 100,000+, one row per city, boroughs of a larger city excluded), then computed each country's spread as its highest city safety score minus its lowest. Ranking by that spread surfaces the most internally divided countries. We use a population floor so the named cities are real, recognisable places rather than tiny geocoded outliers. Scores draw on national travel advisories, local crime data, healthcare infrastructure and night-safety measures; full weighting is at https://kakapo.travel/about/methodology. Scores are comparative model estimates, not official ratings.
Free to cite in journalism, research or content — all we ask is a link back. Copy the attribution below:
Kakapo Editorial Team (2026). The Divided Countries: Where Safety Swings Most From City to City. Kakapo. https://kakapo.travel/blog/divided-countries-2026
Writing a destination, risk or travel-safety story? We give journalists custom data pulls at no cost — the full spread table, a specific country's city-by-city breakdown, or the safest and least-safe city in any nation. Email [email protected] and we usually reply the same day.
Republish the graphic below — the image links back here automatically. Or pull the raw numbers from the open dataset.
Kakapo publishes real safety scores for every destination, drawing on national travel advisories, local crime data, healthcare infrastructure, and night-safety measures. Kakapo Studies is our research imprint — independent editorial, no advertiser influence on scores. Contact: [email protected].